“If history reveals any categorical truth, it is that an insufficient taste for evidence regularly brings out the worst in us.”
I personally went atheist back in 2002, not knowing there was an entire universe of critical thinkers debating the concept of irrational and illogical religious ideas.
I went to a high school in Toronto that was a melting pot of many different belief systems, such as Judaism, Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, Sikhism, and every variation of those in between.
By grade 10, the fundamental question on religion that got to me was why a supposed “god” would allow the murder of 6 million people who fervently believed in “him,” and allow the suffering of another 20 million humans within my own nationality (Russians during WW2).
This produced a rabbit hole of further questions about how none of the stories within religious texts, whether they were the Torah, Bible, Koran, or Hindu Vedas, had any plausible logic or rationality. Instead, they all presented either fairy tales, or atrocities, genocides, murder, and the promotion of slavery.
Then there were various religious students in my high school saying their beliefs were based on the miracle of a family member surviving something or other, or based on “it’s only rational to believe in a god” — as long as it was their version of god.
What Harris Actually Argues
Sam Harris wrote The End of Faith in the aftermath of September 11th, and it shows. This is not a polite, diplomatic critique of religion. This is a full-frontal assault on the idea that faith — believing things without evidence — deserves ANY respect in modern civilization.
His central argument is straightforward: when people genuinely believe the doctrines of their religion, they act on them. And when those doctrines include martyrdom, holy war, or the persecution of nonbelievers, the results are catastrophic. Not metaphorically. Literally.
Harris goes after the common defense that extremists are “not real Muslims” or “not real Christians.” He argues the extremists are often the ones reading the texts MOST literally. The moderates are cherry-picking. And while moderation is obviously preferable, Harris says it creates a shield that protects fundamentalism from criticism.
That is a deeply uncomfortable argument. And I think he is mostly right.
The Collision of Faith and Reason
One of the most powerful sections of the book deals with conversational taboos. In every other domain — science, medicine, engineering, law — we DEMAND evidence before accepting claims. If your doctor told you to take a medication “on faith,” you would run out of that office.
Yet when it comes to the most consequential questions of human existence, we give religion a free pass. Harris finds this insane, and frankly, so do I.
He also digs into the history of religious violence — the Inquisition, the Crusades, witch burnings, honor killings — and forces you to confront the fact that otherwise normal, compassionate people can commit atrocities when they sincerely believe God is on their side.
Where I Differ From Harris
My anti-religion phase was very brief because I ended up moving to a different city altogether, and after further reading within the texts of history, sociology, anthropology, psychology, and once again even more history, you realize that religion is not the cause of our problems.
It is ultimately human nature that resorts to believing these fantasies because of culture, friends, family, the environment, socioeconomics, and even our biology is wired to believe in fairy tales.
Even if you eliminated organized religion, you would still have the idolizing of people, or things, or places, ascribing to them supernatural fantasies, stories, or abilities to magically make things better. Despite not having a religion in the USSR or North Korea, you still have a “cult of personality” where people will worship whomever they are told, or whomever they believe will bring about a solution to their problems.
After all, we are not logical machines. We cannot be rational and logical about everything. Emotion supersedes most of our decisions in life, and because of that emotion, we also get into trouble by believing in supernatural beings and magical stories.
That is why sometimes we end up believing things that might not be true, simply because it “feels” true.
Harris acknowledges some of this, but I think he underestimates how deeply wired we are for belief. Strip away religion and the tribal impulse just finds a new costume — politics, celebrity worship, nationalism, conspiracy theories. The monkey-brain WANTS to belong to something bigger than itself.
Growing Up as a Species
We are slowly growing up as a species. Most men no longer die before the age of 40 because of unnecessarily brutal wars. Most women are no longer slaves to their men. Children are probabilistically going to survive into their 80s and 90s, instead of dying before the age of 3. And you are unlikely to be burned alive because you simply believe in a different version of the story of Jesus Christ (Orthodox, Catholic, Protestant, etc.).
We also no longer believe that genocide, slavery, or subjugation of women and children is acceptable. We do not need to sacrifice humans to the gods. We do not need to burn witches because our crops failed.
As such, just like the tooth fairy and Santa Claus, we will grow out of strong beliefs in religion, and slowly transition into cherry-picking what we believe in the Bible, down to saying, “I believe in god, but not the church,” to “I’m just spiritual,” to “Let’s just make sure we are happy while we are here on this earth.”
In the end, everyone is an atheist, because you do not believe in the other 999,999 gods out there.
Final Thoughts
The End of Faith was the book that launched Sam Harris into the public sphere, and you can feel the urgency in every chapter. Having also reviewed Lying, The Moral Landscape, The Four Horsemen, and Making Sense — I can say this is Harris at his most raw and uncompromising. His later work is more refined, but this one has a fire to it that the others don’t match.
Is it a perfect book? No. Harris occasionally paints with too broad a brush. But the CORE argument — that faith without evidence is dangerous and should not be exempt from criticism — is rock solid.
If you are interested in the intersection of religion, reason, and the future of civilization, this is essential reading. 4/5.
Thanks for reading.
— Leonidas