Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies Review

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies Review

Book Review History
Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies Review
Guns, Germs, and Steel by Jared Diamond Read it on Amazon →
An epic, exhaustive exploration of why some civilizations conquered and others didn’t.

“History followed different courses for different peoples because of differences among peoples’ environments, not because of biological differences among peoples themselves.”

— Jared Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel

This was a tough book to get through. I honestly read it because a few years ago, I read The Pursuit of Glory: Europe 1648–1815. That was the most extensive coverage of European history I have ever read. Down to the diseases, religions, roads, diets, cultures, prejudices, and everything that people engaged, experienced, and suffered at the time.

So Guns, Germs, and Steel was round two in my conquest to learn everything. I will admit though, just like Pursuit of Glory, I had a hard time reading it because of how intricate it is. The main question being, why did Europe end up dominating the world, while other continents (the Middle East, Far East, the Americas, Australia, Greenland, etc.) were still in the stone age, isolated, or had no chance? Why did these places end up becoming European colonies and not Asian colonies, or Australian Aboriginal colonies? And my own personal question… why is European history always emphasized in all major events?

Digging deep into the why…

Everything from Vegetables to Warfare

Anyways, the author covers everything: from what kind of vegetables grew where and on what continent, to the geographic layouts of countries, to the weather, rainfall, animal domestication, and everything in between. The mind sort of glazes through these sections. There is only so much I can read about different wheats, and plants, and cows, and pigs.

But then we get into the germs… more specifically, how societies that developed germs (indirectly, of course) completely annihilated millions of people wherever they went. When Europeans came to the Americas, they decimated their populations through diseases more than anything. 90–95% of Native Americans died from viruses and bacteria that Europeans had built immunities to over the centuries. It is very interesting to read about how European people annihilated the Native Americans, Aboriginal Australians, and even Africans. Not to be outdone by the Asian regions annihilating each other for centuries.

Furthermore, constant fighting within the Eurasian (Europe + Western Asia) regions allowed the rapid development of technologies (obviously to kill each other more efficiently). This technology was, of course, used to “assimilate” any new people (i.e., kill, enslave, or subjugate everything that wasn’t like you).

Geography Is Destiny

One of the most fascinating arguments Diamond makes is about the SHAPE of continents. Eurasia runs east-to-west, meaning crops and livestock could spread along similar latitudes and climates. Wheat that grew in Mesopotamia could thrive in Spain. Horses domesticated in Central Asia could be ridden in France.

Now compare that to Africa and the Americas, which run north-to-south. A crop that flourishes in Mexico has to cross deserts, mountains, and completely different climate zones to reach Peru. That geographic barrier alone set certain civilizations back by THOUSANDS of years.

When you think about it like that, it becomes clear that no group of people was inherently smarter or more ambitious than another. Some just got dealt a better geographic hand. The Fertile Crescent had wheat, barley, and a dozen domesticable animals. Australia had… kangaroos. Good luck building a cavalry on kangaroos.

Europe’s Rise

After the fall of the Roman Empire, and up until the 1500s, Europe was a suppressed place to be. Many innovations instead came from the Middle East and China. Unfortunately, due to bad policy decisions involving religious intolerance to innovation in the Middle East, and closing naval trade in China, those areas paused their potential for domination.

Instead, European nations, due to their extreme segmentation (no one agreed on anything, and constant fighting), resulted in rapid technological breakthroughs. For a long time, Europe was divided into 1,000+ separate states, rather than the 40 countries we are familiar with now. Those 1,000+ states were fighting nonstop.

And here’s the irony — that chaos was actually Europe’s SECRET WEAPON. Because no single ruler could unify the continent, every little kingdom had to innovate or die. When one state rejected an idea (Columbus got turned down by multiple monarchs before Spain said yes), another state picked it up. Competition bred progress. China, by contrast, was one massive empire — and when the emperor decided to ban ocean exploration, that was it. Game over. No second opinion.

The Bigger Picture

On a more pattern-like idea, societies that went from hunter-gatherers to farming were able to sustain larger societies, develop more diseases to kill others who were not immune, and ultimately create more people for armies and potential for innovation.

Finally, as a human species, we’ve gone from just small bands of scavengers, to larger tribes, to large groups commanded by chiefs, and ultimately to states (50,000+ people). At each step of the way, we conquered each other using whatever we had (guns, germs, or steel).

It’s hard to imagine that at one point we were just thousands of little bands and tribes all scattered around the Earth, all speaking our own languages, all doing what bacteria do… reproducing and surviving. Then of course, we became more complicated (religion, social stratifications, technology, warfare, etc.), but the primary motive remains the same.

Why This Book Matters

Here’s what I keep coming back to — Diamond essentially demolished the racist narrative that some civilizations succeeded because their people were genetically superior. Nope. It was geography, climate, available crops, and domesticable animals. That’s it. The rest is downstream consequences playing out over 13,000 years.

If you swap the populations of Europe and Australia at the start of human civilization, the Aboriginal Australians would’ve built the empires and the Europeans would’ve been the ones throwing boomerangs. ENVIRONMENT shaped history, not biology. And once you internalize that idea, you can never look at the world the same way again.

Once again, this book is epic, detailed, and difficult to read. But if you get through, then you’ve earned yourself a “Master of Understanding the History of Human Societies for the Entire Globe and the WHY of It All” cookie.

Book A- (for being hard to read sometimes).

P.S. I won’t lie. I started reading this in January 2015… stopped after one month, and then pushed through in August 2015.

Thanks for reading.

— Leonidas

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies Review

Enjoyed this review?

Pick up Jared Diamond's book and support the blog.

Read it on Amazon →
Written by

Leonidas K.

Since 2010, Leonidas has been an incredible Web Developer, and amazing Digital Marketer. He is the author of various exciting case studies in digital marketing, most notably in Pay Per Call Marketing. Make sure to read the case studies to make your life so much better!

Leave a Comment

Leave a Comment
Sign in with Google
or

Comment posted!